| Platinum | Black Canyon Restaurant |
| Gold | Fort Wayne's Famous Coney Island |
| Silver | Coney Dog Cafe |
| Bronze | Haru Sushi Izakaya |
| Top Pick | Dos Margaritas |
| Top Pick | Fort Wayne Famous Coney Island |
| Top Pick | Nine Mile Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Proximo |
| Top Pick | Salvatori's |
| Top Pick | Ziffle's Rib Bar |