| Platinum | Sweets On Main |
| Gold | Zesto Ice Cream |
| Silver | The Stand |
| Bronze | Oh Five Scoop Shop |
| Top Pick | Brooklyn Pints Microcreamery |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | Just Cream Ice Cream Boutique |
| Top Pick | Kilwin's |
| Top Pick | Moo-Over |
| Top Pick | Sweet Monster |