| Platinum | Smokey Bones Fort Wayne |
| Gold | Brooks BBQ and Chicken |
| Silver | Shigs in Pit |
| Bronze | Acme by Full Circle |
| Top Pick | Big Hungry BBQ |
| Top Pick | Bo Doogies BBQ |
| Top Pick | Lucille's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Lucky Turtle Moose Grill and Lounge |
| Top Pick | Yard Bones2 BBQ & Catering |
| Top Pick | Ziffle's Rib Bar |