| Platinum | Handmade By Bek |
| Gold | Old Fort Soap Company |
| Silver | Fae's Cabinet |
| Bronze | Acacias Journeys |
| Top Pick | Boudoir Noir Romance & Fantasy Boutique |
| Top Pick | Cedar Creek Candles |
| Top Pick | Cog and Pearl |
| Top Pick | Fancy & Staple |
| Top Pick | Foellinger-Freimann Botanical Conservatory Gift Shop |
| Top Pick | Ravenswolf Emporium Metaphysical Shoppe |