| Platinum | Salvatori's |
| Gold | Casa Ristorante Italiano |
| Silver | Casa Grille Italiano |
| Bronze | The Italian Connection |
| Top Pick | 816 Pint & Slice |
| Top Pick | Antonuccio's |
| Top Pick | Oley's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Raimondo's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ziano's Italian eatery |