| Platinum | The Tattooed Cookie LLC |
| Gold | The Sassy Vegan |
| Silver | Icing For Izaac |
| Bronze | Taye's Treats LLC |
| Top Pick | Caking At Midnight |
| Top Pick | Chef's Kitchen |
| Top Pick | George's Labaguette |
| Top Pick | Heathers Cakes and Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Sassie Cakes |
| Top Pick | Tameka's Cakes & Desserts |